A severe hailstorm hits your neighborhood. The vinyl siding on the North side of your house is riddled with holes.
You file a claim. The adjuster comes out and says:
"Good news! We will pay to replace the siding on the North wall."
You ask: "What about the other three walls? The siding is 15 years old and faded. You can't buy that color anymore."
The adjuster smiles and says: "Sorry, the other walls aren't damaged. We only pay for direct damage."
The Result: Your house ends up with two different colors of siding. It looks terrible, and your property value plummets.
This is the "Matching" nightmare. Here is how to avoid it.
Disclaimer: Insurance laws vary significantly by state. "Matching States" (like Ohio, Kentucky, Florida) have statutes protecting homeowners, while others do not. Always verify your local state statutes.
Storm Damaged One Wall?
1. The Problem: "Obsolete" Materials
Building materials fade over time. Manufacturers discontinue colors and styles every few years to cut costs.
- Vinyl Siding: Even if you find the exact same brand/model, the new batch won't match the sun-faded old siding.
- Roof Shingles: A patch of new black shingles will stand out like a sore thumb on a grey, weathered roof (the "Checkerboard" effect).
- Hardwood Floors: If a pipe bursts and ruins half the living room floor, sanding and staining typically fails to achieve a seamless match with the hallway.
2. The Insurer's Defense: "Direct Physical Loss"
Standard ISO Homeowners policies (HO-3) state they cover "Direct Physical Loss."
Since the hail didn't physically touch the South wall, technically, there is no "loss" there.
Insurers argue: "We are obligated to return the home to a functional condition, not necessarily a cosmetically perfect one."
3. The Solution: "Matching of Undamaged Property" Endorsement
To protect yourself, you typically need to add a specific endorsement to your policy called "Matching of Undamaged Property" (or Siding and Roofing Restoration Coverage).
✅ What It Covers
If the damaged materials cannot be matched (due to fading or discontinuation), this coverage pays to replace the undamaged portions as well, ensuring a uniform look.
- Limit: Usually capped at $10,000 or $20,000 per claim (check this limit carefully).
- Cost: Adds about $40 - $80 per year to your premium (well worth it).
4. The "Line of Sight" Rule
Some states protect consumers with a legal concept called the "Line of Sight" rule.
This rule says: "If the replaced area is visible from the same line of sight as the undamaged area, and a reasonable match cannot be found, the insurer must replace everything in that sightline."
The Catch: Insurers often argue about angles. If the North wall (damaged) and East wall (undamaged) meet at a corner, are they in the same line of sight? Insurers often say "No," forcing you to fight for it.
5. Can You Fight It? (Yes, You Can)
If you don't have the endorsement and the insurer refuses to match, follow these steps:
- The ITEL Report: Send a sample of your siding/shingle to ITEL Laboratories. They provide a scientific report proving the material is unavailable. This is your strongest evidence.
- Contractor's Letter: Have your contractor write a statement that the material is "Obsolete" and repairs cannot be performed properly without it.
- Hire a Public Adjuster: If the claim is large (e.g., a full roof or whole house siding), consider hiring a Public Adjuster. They represent you, not the insurance company, and specialize in fighting matching claims.
Don't Settle for Two-Tone
Your home is your biggest investment. A mismatched exterior signals "cheap repair" to future buyers and lowers resale value.
For the price of a nice dinner out, the "Matching Coverage" endorsement saves you from a cosmetic disaster.
Action Plan:
- Look at your Declarations Page for "Matching of Undamaged Property" or "Siding/Roofing Restoration."
- If missing, email your agent today: "If my siding is damaged and discontinued, do you cover full replacement to match?"
- If they say no, ask to add the endorsement immediately.
Helpful Resources:
Adjusters International: The Battle of Matching
United Policyholders: Matching Unmatched Items Guide
0 Comments