💎 The Solitary Stud Dilemma
You own a flawless pair of diamond stud earrings valued at $5,000.
During a beach trip, one falls into the sand and disappears. You still possess the remaining earring, but the utility of a single stud is negligible.
You file a claim. The adjuster's initial logic seems mathematically sound but practically flawed: "The pair is insured for $5,000. You lost half. Here is a check for $2,500."
This is unacceptable. You cannot buy a "matching set" for $2,500. This is where the "Pair and Set Clause" becomes your financial lifesaver.
Lost One Earring?
1. Leveraging the "Pair and Set" Clause
Most "Scheduled Personal Property" endorsements (floaters) contain this specific provision. It recognizes that the value of a set (earrings, cufflinks, candlesticks) is significantly greater than the sum of its individual parts.
The Insurer typically has two contractual options.
- Option A (Repair/Replace): They attempt to locate an exact match to restore the set to its original value. (For custom or vintage jewelry, this is often impossible).
- Option B (Difference in Value): They pay the difference between the value of the set before the loss ($5,000) and the value of the remaining part after the loss (often just scrap gold value, e.g., $100).
The Result: You surrender the remaining earring to the insurer (Salvage), and they cut you a check for the full $5,000.
The Outcome: Instead of being stuck with one useless earring and half the money, you receive the full replacement cost to purchase a brand new pair.
2. Beyond Jewelry (Antiques & Furniture)
This clause is equally critical for other high-value collections.
- Antique Silver: A pair of 19th-century candlesticks might be worth $3,000 together, but a single one is merely a paperweight worth $200. The insurer covers the loss of the set's integrity.
- Custom Furniture: If a fire ruins one chair in a custom dining set of eight, and the fabric is out of production, the insurer may be obligated to replace the entire set of eight to ensure uniformity.
💡 Chief Editor’s Verdict
"Schedule" It or Lose It.
Here is the catch: Standard homeowners policies generally do not cover "losing" items (Mysterious Disappearance). They only cover theft or fire.
To benefit from the Pair and Set clause for a lost earring, you must have the item "Scheduled" (listed separately on a rider/floater). It costs about 1-2% of the value per year but guarantees full protection against accidental loss.
⚖️ Insurance & Legal Disclaimer
Salvage Rights: Be aware that if the insurance company pays you the full value of the set, they have the legal right to take ownership of the remaining item (the "Salvage"). You typically cannot keep the single earring and get the full check.
State Specifics (CA, NY, FL):
• California & New York: These states have strong "Valued Policy" laws for scheduled items. If you have an "Agreed Value" policy, the payout amount is fixed at the time of insurance, avoiding disputes over current market value.
• Unscheduled Limits: Without a specific rider, most policies cap jewelry theft coverage at $1,500 total, subject to your deductible. Always check your specific policy limits ("Special Limits of Liability").
0 Comments